When Star Wars and P&P collide

My sister, Kayleen, had my name for Christmas this year.  Yes, this post is about my Christmas presents.  Yes, tomorrow is Valentine's Day.  Anyway, Kayleen sent  my family so many cool Star Wars related Christmas gifts that my family of nerds was happier than the Rebel Alliance after Luke blew up the Death Star.
 
Here are my two favorites:
 
Han Solo in carbonite cover for my phone. 
 

Big hands, I know you're the one.


And I actually had some dude follow me into a parking lot just so he could take a picture of our Nerd Family Decals:
I mean, what is cooler than that?   The only thing I can think of was the time that HAN SHOT FIRST. 

Something that is equally cool is that a couple weeks ago it was the 200 anniversary of the release of Pride and Prejudice.  And I was dreaming up a blog post about it all day long, and then evening came and I sat down to watch the Keira Knightley P&P movie in honor of the anniversary, and then I didn't blog at all.  I do kind of like that adaption... but mostly just for those times when you need a quick Mr. Darcy fix. 

Good things about the Keira Knightley version:
1.  Jane is actually pretty.  Because the Colin Firth version of P&P is pretty much the best thing ever created in the history of puffy shirts, but Jane is... just... she's not...  no offense to the actress who portrays her who is probably a wonderful human being... but...  she's just.  NO.
2.  Wickham is handsome, although perhaps not the best actor.  Still... handsome.
3.  Although the first proposal scene kind of strays a bit from the book... whoo Nelly!  There was some sexual tension there.  I do not hate.
4.  The meadow scene.  I understand, yes.. this would never have happened in 1813 England, Lizzy walking around outside in her nightdress, being approached by a half-clothed Mr. Darcy.  I know!  But still, so romantical!  It's a little swoony. 
5.  I do think Judi Dench makes a good Lady Catherine.

Bad things about the Keira Knightley version:
1.  The Bennets did not have a male heir so their fortune was entailed away from their family, but they did not live in squalor.  A pig wandering through the house?  Come on.  They were portrayed much dirtier than I believe Jane Austen intended. 
2.  Mrs. Bennet acts like a loving although-occasionally-neurotic mother.  In the book, she's just straight up neurotic.  I love her, she reminds me of my own mom.  I don't want a kinder, gentler Mrs. Bennet.  The fact that Lizzy's parents don't love each other is a HUGE theme in the book, and this version completely leaves it out. 
3.  That "Mrs. Darcy, Mrs. Darcy, Mrs. Darcy" cheese fest at the very end of the film.  Hija mia.  


Anyway, that was riveting, I'm sure.  How about if I go through the Star Wars Prequels to tell you all the things that suck about them?  Actually, that would be easy.

Star Wars Prequels

First scene?  Sucks.

Final scene?  Mega sucks
Everything in between?  The suckiest bunch of suck that ever did suck.

The End.

Also, terrible terrible dialogue and the most wooden acting imaginable.  BOOOOOOO!!!!!!


I am now imagining a Star Wars/Pride and Prejudice Nerd ball, combining my two great loves.  Maybe the men can come dressed up like Han Solo and the women in Regency garb?  This might be the only way to get husbands to an Austen ball.  I think I might be a genius. 

Laura  – (February 13, 2013 at 5:22 PM)  

I think you may be onto something, there. You should also write a combo P&P/SW novel - a la Pride and Prejudice and Zombies. Han Solo could be, say, Mr. Darcy. Mr. Bennett is, of course, Darth Vader. No?

Claire  – (February 13, 2013 at 6:47 PM)  

This is the first time I've seen anyone comment on Jane in the Firth P&P...and I totally agree! Horse-face much? I am sure she is a very nice person...just totally mis-cast.

I do prefer the Firth version, though. So much richer. However, for a two-hour swoonfest, I can definitely appreciate the Knightly version. :D

Ami  – (February 14, 2013 at 6:20 AM)  

As far as two hour versions go, I love the Keira Knightly version. The first words out of my mouth were a loud "Hot dang! Jane is actually pretty!" Too bad I was in a movie theater at the time.
I especially love the music throughout the movie and how Darcy's hand twitches after he helps Lizzie into the carriage. My heart almost explodes with delightful thumping every time I watch that scene.

Sharon  – (February 14, 2013 at 7:15 AM)  

Seriously? Star Wars, Pride and Prejudice, AND Violent Femmes? Were we separated at birth?

Anonymous –   – (February 14, 2013 at 9:25 AM)  

Ok. I have never seen ANY of these movies. Not a single Star Wars. No version of P&P. I am a nerd virgin. But I want to experience these.

I want to start with Star Wars. Should I skip the suckfest that is the prequil? I have Netflix and a ROKU. Someone point me toward the order I should watch, please?

And then for P&P, which should I watch first? If anyone could suggest a watching order and what to skip, I would be very grateful!

I am recovering from an injury and pretty much glued to my couch. I'm so bored! Turn me into a proper respectable nerd!

Mary  – (February 14, 2013 at 10:15 AM)  

Anonymous, start with Star Wars episode 4 titled A New Hope. Then watch Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi. But never under any circumstances watch episodes 1-3.

If you've got time (and it sounds like you do!) I would start with the Colin Firth Pride and Prejudice. It is the best adaptation except the one tiny problem of Jane. And if you like it, then you can watch the Keira Knightley version.

Enjoy!

Anonymous –   – (February 14, 2013 at 12:22 PM)  

Mary, that was a hillarious post. I didn't realize what we had in common living in Yakim but after reading your posts I'm becoming more of a Star Wars/P&P nerd. Have you ever seen the P&P version from 1940? If you haven't, don't. Its worst than the SW prequels and I actually do like some of the prequels. Cmon, Ewan McGregor?

muhammad ibraheem  – (February 18, 2013 at 4:35 PM)  

Investment Plans to make money online, Online Jobs can make money online from home, Just Visit
www.jobzcorner.com

  © Blogger template Shush by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP